review-loop

Solid

Convergence-paced review-resolve loop over code/PR diffs. Drives a pluggable review source (codex | code-review), verifies each finding against the codebase and the work-flow, auto-applies mechanical fixes and gates judgment fixes with the user, then re-reviews until the source verdict reaches approve. User-invoked via /review-loop.

Code & Development 125 stars 11 forks Updated today MIT

Install

View on GitHub

Quality Score: 84/100

Stars 20%
70
Recency 20%
100
Frontmatter 20%
70
Documentation 15%
100
Issue Health 10%
50
License 10%
100
Description 5%
100

Skill Content

# Review Loop A source-agnostic, convergence-paced review-resolve loop for code/PR diffs: it drives a pluggable review source to convergence (verdict=approve), auto-applying mechanical fixes and gating the judgment calls. ## Caller Signature ``` /review-loop [source?] [scope?] source : { codex | code-review } -- optional; review source behind the (diff, design-intent) → { findings[], verdict } interface -- absent → Phase 0 asks which source to use (no default; one invokable source relays, zero stops) scope : PR number | (implicit) -- optional; PR number, or implicit current-PR / working-tree detection ``` The review source is pluggable: any source satisfying the `(diff, design-intent) → { findings[], verdict }` interface can drive the loop. `codex` and `code-review` are the two sources documented in the Source Interface section; both are runtime-selected, not fixed at definition time. When `source` is omitted, Phase 0 asks which source to use (no preselected default; with exactly one invokable source it relays the designation, with none it stops). When `scope` is omitted, Phase 0 detects it (current-branch PR or working tree). ## Pipeline Overview ``` /review-loop [source?] [scope?] Phase 0 : source designation (arg → relay | absent → ask, cardinality-guarded) + scope detect (PR diff | working tree) + design-intent harvest (rules/comments for th...

Details

Author
jongwony
Repository
jongwony/epistemic-protocols
Created
7 months ago
Last Updated
today
Language
JavaScript
License
MIT

Bundled in these plugins

Similar Skills

Semantically similar based on skill content — not just same category

Code & Development Listed

review-loop

Dispatches a multi-agent review team over the work in this session, runs an execution-grounded check (lint/test/build), validates findings through a falsifier stage, addresses load-bearing issues, and re-reviews until clean or budget hits. On the terminal verdict, always records a commit-pinned verdict comment on the branch's open PR (if one exists), so the review leaves a trail. Invoked manually as /review-loop or automatically by the Stop hook after real work outside plan mode. Use `--mode claim` to review a non-code analytical conclusion (a research finding or comparison verdict) by sending reviewers back to its primary sources to falsify it.

0 Updated today
BryceEWatson
Code & Development Listed

review-loop

Review an explicit plan/code/PR SHA delta with a risk-scaled panel, fix one complete finding batch, validate the changed delta, and emit a durable review receipt. Defaults to one reviewer, adds targeted lenses for sensitive work, caps normal finding-bearing rounds, and avoids re-reading already certified branch history. Only invoke as `$review-loop` / `/review-loop`, or when a delivery skill calls it. Works identically under Codex and Claude Code.

0 Updated 2 days ago
comment-hq
AI & Automation Listed

loop-review

Independently review one loop iteration's implementation diff against the product contract and report a verdict (APPROVE, REVISE with must-fix items, or — at the gate — ESCALATE to the human). Requirement-first — per-REQ satisfaction is judged before code quality; the gate renders a machine-parsed verdict per REQ. Runs read-only with fresh context; driven by loop.sh, not for ad-hoc use.

0 Updated 2 days ago
Aitne-sh