nw-par-review-criteria
FeaturedQuality dimensions and review checklist for devop reviews
Code & Development 636 stars
68 forks Updated today MIT
Install
Quality Score: 95/100
Stars 20%
Recency 20%
Frontmatter 20%
Documentation 15%
Issue Health 10%
License 10%
Description 5%
Skill Content
# DevOp Reviewer: Review Criteria
## Critique Dimension 1: Incomplete Phase Handoffs
**Pattern**: Phase handoffs missing required artifacts or approvals.
**Required per Phase**:
- DISCUSS: Requirements document + peer review approval
- DESIGN: Architecture document + ADRs + peer review approval
- DISTILL: Acceptance tests + peer review approval
- DELIVER: Production code + tests (100% passing) + peer review approval
**Severity**: critical. Verify all artifacts present and peer-reviewed before phase transition.
---
## Critique Dimension 2: Deployment Readiness Gaps
**Pattern**: Feature marked "ready" but missing production prerequisites.
**Required**: All tests passing (100%) | Production configuration complete | Monitoring/alerting configured | Runbook/operational docs created | Rollback plan documented.
**Severity**: critical. Complete missing prerequisite before marking deployment-ready.
---
## Critique Dimension 3: Traceability Violations
**Pattern**: Cannot trace production code back to requirements.
**Required**: User stories map to acceptance tests | Acceptance tests map to production code | Code changes traceable to commits | All AC verified in production.
**Severity**: high. Establish traceability chain: user-story -> acceptance-tests -> code-commits.
---
## Critique Dimension 4: Priority Validation
**Purpose**: Validate roadmap addresses largest bottleneck first, not secondary concern.
### Questions
**Q1: Is this the largest bottleneck?**
Does timi...
Details
- Author
- nWave-ai
- Repository
- nWave-ai/nWave
- Created
- 9 months ago
- Last Updated
- today
- Language
- Python
- License
- MIT
Similar Skills
Semantically similar based on skill content — not just same category
DevOps & Infrastructure Featured
nw-par-critique-dimensions
Platform design review critique dimensions and severity levels. Load when reviewing CI/CD pipelines, infrastructure, deployment strategies, observability, or security designs.
636 Updated today
nWave-ai Code & Development Featured
nw-sc-review-dimensions
Reviewer critique dimensions for peer review - implementation bias detection, test quality validation, completeness checks, and priority validation
636 Updated today
nWave-ai Code & Development Featured
nw-po-review-dimensions
Requirements quality critique dimensions for peer review - confirmation bias detection, completeness validation, clarity checks, testability assessment, and priority validation
636 Updated today
nWave-ai