nw-sa-critique-dimensions
FeaturedArchitecture quality critique dimensions for peer review. Load when invoking solution-architect-reviewer or performing self-review of architecture documents.
AI & Automation 636 stars
68 forks Updated today MIT
Install
Quality Score: 95/100
Stars 20%
Recency 20%
Frontmatter 20%
Documentation 15%
Issue Health 10%
License 10%
Description 5%
Skill Content
# Architecture Quality Critique Dimensions
## Dimension 1: Architectural Bias Detection
### Technology Preference Bias
Pattern: tech chosen by preference, not requirements. Detection: ADR lacks comparison matrix, choice not mapped to requirements, justified only as "best practice." Severity: HIGH.
### Resume-Driven Development
Pattern: complex/trendy tech without requirement justification. Examples: microservices for 3-person team, Kafka for 100 req/day, service mesh without complexity. Detection: complexity exceeds team size/requirements, tech adds resume value not solves problem. Severity: CRITICAL.
### Latest Technology Bias
Pattern: unproven tech (<6 months, small community) for production. Detection: check maturity, community, LTS, fallback plan. Severity: HIGH.
## Dimension 2: ADR Quality Validation
### Missing Context
ADR lacks business problem, technical constraints, or quality attribute requirements. Future maintainers cannot validate. Severity: HIGH.
### Missing Alternatives Analysis
No alternatives (min 2 required). Each must be evaluated against requirements with rejection rationale. Severity: HIGH.
### Missing Consequences
Omits positive/negative consequences and trade-offs. Quality attribute impact not analyzed. Severity: MEDIUM.
## Dimension 3: Completeness Validation
### Missing Quality Attributes
Architecture doesn't address required attributes. Verify: performance (latency, throughput) | scalability | security (auth, data protection) | maintainabil...
Details
- Author
- nWave-ai
- Repository
- nWave-ai/nWave
- Created
- 9 months ago
- Last Updated
- today
- Language
- Python
- License
- MIT
Similar Skills
Semantically similar based on skill content — not just same category
AI & Automation Featured
nw-sar-critique-dimensions
Architecture quality critique dimensions for peer review. Load when performing architecture document reviews.
636 Updated today
nWave-ai Code & Development Featured
nw-sc-review-dimensions
Reviewer critique dimensions for peer review - implementation bias detection, test quality validation, completeness checks, and priority validation
636 Updated today
nWave-ai Code & Development Featured
nw-po-review-dimensions
Requirements quality critique dimensions for peer review - confirmation bias detection, completeness validation, clarity checks, testability assessment, and priority validation
636 Updated today
nWave-ai