argument-mapping

# Argument Mapping Map argument structures for research domains. Extracts claims from sources, links supporting and opposing evidence, assesses argument strength, and synthesizes coherent positions from complex debates. ## Manifest | Level | Count | Skills | |-------|-------|--------| | Strategy | 3 | claim-extraction, evidence-linking-arg, argument-synthesis | | Tactic | 2 | claim-decomposition, strength-assessment | | SOP | 6 | claim-page-creation, rebuttal-documentation, evidence-attachment, strength-scoring, argument-visualization, synthesis-report | ## Budget Table | Metric | Small | Medium | Large | |--------|-------|--------|-------| | Claims extracted | 10 | 25 | 50 | | Evidence links created | 15 | 40 | 80 | | Rebuttals documented | 3 | 10 | 20 | | Strength scores assigned | 10 | 25 | 50 | | Synthesis reports | 1 | 3 | 5 | ## Strategy Sequence (Reference, Not Prescription) 1. **claim-extraction** — identify and extract claims from source material 2. **evidence-linking-arg** — link evidence to claims (supporting, contradicting, qualifying) 3. **argument-synthesis** — synthesize positions from the argument graph ## MCP Tools Used - `vault_search` — find existing claims and evidence - `vault_add_edge` — create argument edges (supported_by, contradicts, derived_from) - `vault_query_graph` — trace argument chains - `vault_graph_stats` — assess argument coverage - `vault_lint` — validate structural integrity ## Context-Management <HARD-GATE> - Call `context-init...