nw-diverger-review-criteria
FeaturedReview criteria for the nw-diverger-reviewer — validates JTBD rigor, research quality, option diversity, taste application correctness, and recommendation coherence in DIVERGE wave artifacts
Code & Development 636 stars
68 forks Updated today MIT
Install
Quality Score: 95/100
Stars 20%
Recency 20%
Frontmatter 20%
Documentation 15%
Issue Health 10%
License 10%
Description 5%
Skill Content
# Diverger Review Criteria
## Role
You are reviewing DIVERGE wave artifacts. Your job is adversarial: assume artifacts have problems until you prove they don't. Flag issues before the team commits to a design direction.
Four artifact files to review:
- `docs/feature/{id}/diverge/job-analysis.md`
- `docs/feature/{id}/diverge/competitive-research.md`
- `docs/feature/{id}/diverge/options-raw.md`
- `docs/feature/{id}/diverge/taste-evaluation.md`
- `docs/feature/{id}/diverge/recommendation.md`
---
## Dimension 1: JTBD Rigor
### Check 1.1 — Abstraction Level
**Requirement**: Job must be at strategic or physical level, not tactical.
**FAIL signals** (quote from artifact when found):
- Job statement describes a feature: "When I need to see status, I want a dashboard..."
- Job statement contains a solution reference: "When using the app, I want to..."
- Job reads like a user story: "As a developer, I want to..."
**PASS signal**: Job statement answers "what progress is being made?" without specifying how.
### Check 1.2 — First-Principles Extraction
**Requirement**: Evidence of 5-Why or abstraction-layer navigation.
**FAIL signals**:
- Job accepted as stated by user without elevation
- No "why?" chain documented
- Functional, emotional, and social jobs not distinguished
**PASS signal**: At least one level of elevation documented, from the raw request to the extracted job.
### Check 1.3 — Outcome Statement Quality
**Requirement**: ODI-format outcome statements (Minimize + ...
Details
- Author
- nWave-ai
- Repository
- nWave-ai/nWave
- Created
- 9 months ago
- Last Updated
- today
- Language
- Python
- License
- MIT
Similar Skills
Semantically similar based on skill content — not just same category
AI & Automation Featured
nw-diverge
Generates 3-5 divergent design directions through JTBD analysis, competitive research, structured brainstorming, and taste evaluation before convergence. Use when the team has a validated problem but hasn't chosen a solution approach.
636 Updated today
nWave-ai Code & Development Featured
nw-por-review-criteria
Review dimensions and bug patterns for journey artifact reviews
636 Updated today
nWave-ai Code & Development Featured
nw-dr-review-criteria
Critique dimensions, severity framework, verdict decision matrix, and review output format for documentation assessment reviews
636 Updated today
nWave-ai